12 October 2012

Working Condition Survey by NYLC











Circular No 215/2012
Dated 4 Oct 2012


To Members of the Malaysian Bar and pupils in chambers

The National Working Conditions Survey Report and Working Conditions Forum:
The Bigger Better Deal for Everyone? (20 Oct 2012)
We refer to Circular No 225/2011 dated 5 Oct 2011 and Circular No 276/2011 dated 23 Nov 2011, wherein we had disseminated the National Young Lawyers Committee (“NYLC”)’s National Working Conditions Survey (“NWCS”). 

NWCS
At the 4th Young Lawyers Convention (“Convention”), held from 1 to 3 July 2011 at Malacca, the delegates of the Convention issued the Malacca Statement which mandated the NYLC to conduct a national working conditions survey to review the working conditions of younger Members of the Bar and the remuneration schemes received by them. 

NWCS was disseminated to Members and pupils in chambers all over Malaysia over a course of three months, from October to December 2011.  The NYLC then spent a total of five months thereafter collating, collecting, extracting and preparing the data to be presented as the National Working Conditions Survey Report (“Report”).  Attached please find the Executive Summary of the Report.  Alternatively, click here to download the Executive Summary and 111-page Report.

The NYLC urges Members to read the Executive Summary together with “A Short Review on the Findings, Comparisons and Conclusions”, which can be found at page 93 of the Report highlighting the NYLC’s international and national comparative studies, tables, reports and recommendations. 

NYLC’s Findings: A Summary
From the Report, the current generation of young lawyers in Malaysia are earning the following:

Average Pupils in Chambers’ Allowance
Klang Valley : RM 1,501 to RM 2,000
Outside Klang Valley : RM    500 to RM 1,000

Average First-Year Lawyers’ Salaries
Klang Valley : RM 3,001 to RM 3,500
Outside Klang Valley : RM 2,001 to RM 2,500

The NYLC further discovered that the current generation of young lawyers leans towards the following benefits from their employers: extra technological items (including laptops, tablets and other gadgets except smartphones), dental benefits, weekend allowances, gym benefits, wardrobe allowances, medical benefits and especially for young lawyers outside the Klang Valley, parking and travelling allowances. 

Working Conditions Forum: The Bigger Better Deal for Everyone? (20 Oct 2012)
The NYLC is conducting a forum focusing on the findings of the Report, and to propose recommendations on the ideal working conditions and remuneration packages that the current generation of young lawyers is seeking for. 

The details of the forum are as follows:
Date         : 20 Oct 2012 (Saturday)
Time : 11:00 am to 2:00 pm
Venue :  Raja Aziz Addruse Auditorium, First Floor, Bar Council

The NYLC would like to invite all Members and pupils in chambers, including employers of law firms and in particular, younger members of the Bar to join us at the forum. 

To maximise broadcast and reach out to more Members, the forum will be streamed live at http://www.livestream.com/nationalylc or on our backup channelhttp://www.ustream.tv/channel/nylc.

Please be informed that although this event is open to the public, pre-registration is required, as places are limited.  Kindly complete and return the attached registration form by fax to 03-2031 6640, or by e-mail to ml.tan@malaysianbar.org.my, by 19 Oct 2012 (Friday).

For enquiries, kindly contact Marianna Laureen Tan, Officer, Bar Council, by telephone at 03-2050 2086 or by email at ml.tan@malaysianbar.org.my.

Thank you.

20 September 2012

My Experience as an Intern at RWY - Hoong Wei En


To start things off, I want to thank Mr Richard and Mr Yip for giving me a chance to work and learn alongside them as well as the team at Richard Wee & Yip (RWY) for patiently teaching and guiding me through the two months tenure with them. Having completed my internship programme with Richard Wee & Yip, I can now say that the experience had broadened my horizon, giving me a foretaste of the working environment and the life of a lawyer.

Working was a totally new territory for me and having never to have worked before, I did not know what to expect when I joined Messrs Richard Wee & Yip. I was a mixture of excitement and nervousness when I met Mr Richard for the very first time during my interview.

On my first day, still apprehensive of what was expected in my job as an intern, Mr Yip approached me to sit in on a discussion, which I later found out that it was an arbitration case. I was blessed to be able to work alongside Mr Yip and a claims consultant, learning new terms, phrases and processes, which I have never even heard before. It was a challenge for me, trying to understand and grasp the case but Mr Yip patiently took me through the case.

I spent my first two weeks at the firm doing clerical work and conveyancing matters, filling in CKHT forms, drafting, compiling and mailing out letters. I learnt how to handle the office machines such as the binder, the photocopier and the ancient typewriter.

Aside from clerical work, I got to do research relating to Internet Law for the Legal Tech Forum, where Mr Richard was an invited speaker.  Together with the other lawyers of RWY, I attended the Forum and got new insights to the cyber world and the law governing it.

I was also given the opportunity to sit in on meetings and court cases and it was very eye opening especially when I went to the Palace of Justice. Drafting Letter of Demands, Statement of Claims, and translations of Affidavits in Reply are some of the other things that I do as an intern under the supervision of the other lawyers. Like everything else, it was new to me but I rather enjoyed doing them.

Furthermore, I had the privilege to directly assist Mr Richard and Mr Yip in the pioneer project of Safer Malaysia, which is close to their hearts. Safer Malaysia is a platform for the public to air their grievances and to attempt to push for reforms of our security administration, with the aim to make our country a safer place. In this project, I aided Mr Richard by compiling articles and news on crime, drafting proposals, vision statements and articles as well as research. On many occasions, I followed both Mr Richard and Mr Yip for meetings with government representatives and individuals from other NGOs who are interested in working hand in hand with Safer Malaysia. It is a once in a lifetime opportunity for me to be involved in a project that is so dear to the heart of many Malaysians. Although this is not related to any legal framework, it was very enlightening and through this, I learnt that complaining brings you nowhere. We should instead try to do something to remedy the situation.

Before interning at a law firm, I was of the opinion that I would only be learning very general office work like photostating, binding and making coffee but my experience at Richard Wee & Yip has changed my whole perspective as a law intern. I was given every opportunity to learn and the lawyers as well as the clerks at the firm were patient in teaching and did not withhold any knowledge and impart freely. The people at RWY are also very warm and friendly. This makes the firm a very condusive enviroment for learning. Accordingly when I joined the firm it was a quiet period, I am thankful to still be able to learn many things, both legal and non-legal. Some important principles that I learn from RWY are integrity, sincerity and punctuality. 

Thank you Mr Richard, Mr Yip and the team.

Warmest regards
Wei En, Hoong

18 September 2012

My Experience As An Intern at RWY - Henry Ng


Revelation of the Life of a Law Firm
Learning is a lifetime process, without which even a billionaire cannot preserve his success overtime. The attachment at Messrs Richard Wee & Yip is such an eye-opener pertaining to the life of a lawyer and at the same time, it prepares me to face my own challenges in the future.
Thanks to the past experiences shared by others, wherein I have had the advantage to make reference to, I concur on the sacrifice and contribution by every member of the firm. Because of them, I am further equipped with soft skills and knowledge on certain areas such as drafting and conveyance. With all due respect, I prefer to share what I have learnt from RWY on the aspect of ‘how to be a REAL lawyer’.
A lawyer is often being described as ‘lifeless and dull’, if not ‘cocky and impertinent’. Is that really so? To what extent it is true? Well, while I do not doubt that it may be the case for other lawyers, I am certain that RWY provides friendly working atmosphere and the lawyers are down-to-earth in nature.
Lesson No.1 – treat others with utmost sincerity and courtesy. One of the lawyers, through his experience, once told me that only his colleagues will back him up when he is in deep trouble; a cruel truth of life. I believe that this is the catalyst of the firm in nurturing a relationship of trust and respect among the members of the firm. In the spirit of achieving that, politeness and willingness are prioritised; not seniority. Even I am treated as if I were a qualified lawyer!
Lesson No.2 – enjoy the process and the journey. It is a culture of RWY to give a ‘pat on the shoulder’ when a good job is done and to celebrate anything worth celebrating. During lunchtime, sometimes with the presence of the partners, conversation was exchanged and often ended with laughter. Even the birthdays and the last day of attachments are celebrated in the firm just to appreciate our contribution, as well as recognition as an individual.
Lesson No.3 – show dedication and integrity to the profession. Notwithstanding the fact that we are allowed to err because we are human, works must be done in a systematic and efficient manner. If this code is broken, even the best lawyer will have to face the music. From my observation, RWY is passionate and meticulous on the things it is doing and frowns upon any negligence and irresponsible behavior of the lawyers and employees, especially when it relates to work.
The firm is indeed not only a workplace and a factory but also a big family. Like a Swiss made watch, every member plays a role like a component in a watch. As paramount as it sounds, even the tiniest part fails, the whole watch collapses. While I am not saying that RWY is flawless, because nothing is, I do not question the greatness of this firm. It is good that the attachments learn something of everything. If I have to make any suggestion, I would opine that RWY could allocate the attachments more to the respective areas where they show interests in, if possible. This will not only increase the efficiency of the work done, it may stimulate the potentials of one to the fullest.
‘You can teach a student a lesson for a day; but if you can teach him to learn by creating curiosity, he will continue the learning process as long as he lives’, said Clay. P. Bedford. I am extremely grateful for RWY to have prompted me to question the interpretation and enforcement of law in Malaysia and every doubt has been answered with bluntness without hiding the ugly side of the truth. Once again, thank you for the blessings and wishes RWY has for me. Indebtedness is at least what I can express; the spirit of Messrs’ Richard Wee & Yip is what I will carry.
Henry Ng

23 August 2012

My Experience As An Intern at RWY - Tan Sue Vern


Before I started my attachment at RWY, I was terrified as I didn’t have a clue as to what was going to happen. The only idea I had was that it was going to be different from my previous attachment at a different law firm. I recalled Richard telling me during my interview with him that I would be treated as a lawyer. With the little experience I had, the idea of being treated as a lawyer was extremely daunting. Yet, a little part of me was excited that I would finally get a glimpse of life as a lawyer.

My first day started off on a good note. I got to know others at the firm as well as how the firm worked. I spent my first day learning and doing general clerical tasks. At the risk of sounding like an ignorant person, I actually learnt to do things such as posting letters (i.e knowing what stamps to put, learning about the AR post etc.) I also had the opportunity to learn the clerical side of legal work from Kak Sal who was kind enough to sit me down and teach me the whole process of how a legal suit is initiated and what needs to be done (clerical wise) to file a suit. I remember her telling me, “They will never teach you this at law school”.

As time went on, I started taking on other tasks such as learning how to draft an opinion letter, writing formal letters to clients, and preparing statement of claims and also grounds of appeal for an employment case originating from the Jabatan Tenaga Buruh. I even had the opportunity of writing my own legal opinion to a client under the supervision of one of the legal associates, Ezhan. In addition to that, I also went to court several times. During my court visits, I was able to sit in for awhile to watch criminal proceedings in the magistrate courts, visit the Court of Appeal in Putrajaya (where I met and shook hands with several “star” lawyers such as Edmund Bon and Gobind Singh Deo and also saw Karpal Singh from a distance) as well as to watch a cross examination take place (which was actually quite dramatic). I also had the opportunity of observing how a case is dealt with in the Jabatan Tenaga Buruh.

During my attachment at RWY, I was also fortunate enough to have a glimpse of what conveyancing is like. I learnt about the various forms involved in conveyancing but more importantly, I realised how meticulous one has to be when it comes to conveyancing. I had the opportunity to work with Sarah where she took time off to teach me even the smallest things like formatting on Microsoft Word noting that even small matters such as formatting can have an impact on how you come across as a lawyer to others.

I was also roped in to help out in the Safer Malaysia project. During the planning of the candlelight vigil held by Safer Malaysia, I was able to join in the meetings with several influential people such as the OCPD of Petaling Jaya and Eugene Teh of PEMANDU. The experience of being part of the Safer Malaysia team is definitely an invaluable experience as it is not everyday where one has the opportunity of being involved in a community project of such a scale.

To cut the long story short, my experience at Richard Wee and Yip was definitely enriching. From knowing so little about what it is like to be a lawyer, I definitely have learnt that being a lawyer is not so much about the glitz and the glam like what we see on television but a lot of hard work and perhaps paper work. I also realised that I have so much more to learn not only in terms of legal knowledge but also in terms of character. Having sat in and observing how the lawyers at RWY worked, I realised that it is very important to pay close attention to every detail and to work hard to prepare as much as you can. More importantly, a lawyer must always be organised. Having completed my attachment programme at RWY I realised that what Kak Sal told me at the beginning of my attachment was true. They really don’t teach you all these at law school. To everyone at RWY, thank you so much for your patience and willingness to teach me.

Tan Sue Vern



22 August 2012

When Can a Liquidator Be Removed?



RWY Intern, Caroline Leong trying to make sense of the principles governing the laws when applying to remove a Liquidator


What Is a Liquidator and What Does a Liquidator Do?

A liquidator is a person who manages a company’s assets in the event that the company gets wound up. It should be noted that a company can be wound up in two ways, voluntarily or involuntarily. Involuntary winding up can also be described as the winding up of a company by the Court. When a company is wound up, only an approved liquidator or the Official Receiver may be appointed as the liquidator. Section 227 of the Companies Act 1965 lays out the process of the appointing a liquidator.

A liquidator’s responsibility is to sell the assets and use the proceeds to pay the company’s creditors. Basically he collects all the assets belonging to the company in liquidation before cashing it out to settle all the creditor’s claims. In the event that there are any surplus assets, he will distribute them to the company’s shareholders according to their entitlement.

This article will attempt to answer two questions. Can we remove a liquidator who is appointed by the court and if so, in what circumstances?

Section 232(1) of the Companies Act 1965 states as follows: -

(               " A liquidator appointed by the Court may resign or on cause shown be removed by the Court."


Ng Yok Gee & Anor v CTI Leather Sdn Bhd; Metro Brilliant Sdn Bhd & Ors (Interveners) (2006) 3 CLJ 360 is a case which sets outs the principles of law whereby a liquidator can be removed, which include:-

“The normal ground for removal is that the liquidator has a personal unfitness, has failed to act impartially or is in a position where his duty and interest are in conflict.”

“A liquidator who fails to investigate the affairs of the company to the prejudice of an applicant is in neglect of his duty and can be removed. (In re Sir John Moore Gold Mining Company (supra))”

The court will take into account certain factors such as the majority of creditors being unsatisfied with the liquidator (Re Oxford Building and Investment Co [1883-1884] 49 L.T 495) or whether it would be in the interest of the liquidation for him to be replaced (Chua Boon Chim v JM MacCormack [1979] 2 MLJ 156). In a recent local case, the court stated that it “must be shown that the liquidator can no longer act impartially and objectively to protect” the interest of the liquidation (Wong Sin Fan & 2 Ors v Ng Peak Yam @ Ng Peak Yeow & Anor (2012) 1 AMR 818, CA). 

Therefore, the above Section 232(1) can be understood to mean that the court can remove a liquidator if it can be shown that his removal would be generally advantageous for those interested in the company’s assets (Re Adam Eyton, Limited, Ex Parte Charlesworth (1887) 36 Ch. D 229).



What about a situation where a liquidator faces a vote of no confidence?

As a result, this author feels that a vote of no confidence from the creditors should certainly be a factor to take into account. The judge in the case of Ng Yok Gee & Anor (2006) 3 CLJ 360 felt that it was “not a sufficient ground for removal of a liquidator that a substantial minority or even the majority of shareholders want the liquidator to be removed.” However, this was clarified when the judge in Bina Puri Sdn Bhd v Jambulingam Sethuraman-Raki [2012] 8 MLJ 141 reasoned that if the applicant had shown that “all the creditors and/or contributories play a significant role, the overriding consideration is that the court must be satisfied that it is against the interest of the liquidation.”



What if there is no personal misconduct on the part of the liquidator?

This brings us to the issue of how to define “cause shown”. There are several cases which can be referred to with regards to this. The English Court was of the opinion that the phrase “on due cause shewn” does not have to be confined to “personal unfitness in the liquidator” (Re Adam Eyton (1887) 36 Ch. D 229). In another case, the court was seen as having “a discretionary power to remove the liquidator appointed by a company without any proof of misconduct or unfitness on their part if, having regard to all the circumstance, it is of opinion that their removal will conduce to the more efficient winding up of the company” (Re Marseilles Extension Railway and Land Company [1867] L.R. 4 EQ 692). Furthermore, the court in Re Buildlead Ltd Quickson (South and West) Ltd v Katz and Another [2004] EWHC 2432 (Ch) interpreted a similar phrase, found in Section 108(2) Insolvency Act 1986, to mean:-

                     “The burden is on the applicant to show a good cause for removal of a liquidator, but it is well established that the statutory provision confers a wide discretion on the court which is not dependent on the proof of particular breaches of duty by the liquidator.”


Chi Liung Holdings Sdn Bhd v Soon Kok Seng (liquidator) Chi Liung & Sons Sdn Bhd [1996] 2 BLJ 9 is a Malaysian case stating that there need not be misconduct on the part of the liquidator to enable removal as long as it is “in the best interest of the company being liquidated”. If a liquidator acts “outside the scope of his appointment” or fails to “protect the interest of the creditors and/or contributories”, then he can be removed as well.

The judge in TR Hamzah & Yeang Sdn Bhd v City Centre Sdn Bhd [2012] 1 MLJ 383 clearly explains in his judgment that “cause shown” is to be interpreted in a manner that does not insist on personal misconduct for the removal of a liquidator:-

“There is no specific methodology or formula attached to the word 'cause shown'. The court is obliged to remove the liquidator in limine if he has failed to act within the spirit and intent of the several provisions of the CA 1965 and more importantly when he acts outside the scope of his appointment or order of court or failed to protect the interest of the creditors and/or contributories or is not justly, expeditiously and economically pursuing to conclude the liquidation process as it must not be forgotten that he is an officer of court and his acts or omission must not place the administration of justice to disrepute.”

However, there have been cases where the court takes a different stance. In the recent case of Wong Sin Fan & 2 Ors v Ng Peak Yam @ Ng Peak Yeow & Anor [2012] 1 AMR 818, the Court was seen to be of the opinion that “some unfitness in the liquidator must be shown in order to justify his removal”.

In conclusion there are conflicting authorities as to whether a liquidator can be removed in certain circumstances. However, this author sees this as an opportunity for common law in this area to expand and evolve but of course, it will take time. A judgment which can clarify the law once and for all will certainly be welcomed.



Caroline Leong
22nd August 2012