14 November 2012

We are closed on 16/11/2012


Kindly be informed, that RWY will be closed on 16th November 2012 (Friday) as we will away for our annual Team-Building trip. 

However, for any emergency; please call HW Yip (012-3111580) or Richard Wee (016-2750025).

We will be back in action on 19th November 2012.

We apologise for any inconvenience caused. 


12 November 2012

Happy Deepavali 2012

Richard Wee & Yip, wishes our clients celebrating Deepavali, a good Deepavali.


01 November 2012

Press Release: Bar Council Surveys Explore Employability of New Law Graduates and Working Conditions of Young Lawyers



The standards of lawyers at the Malaysian Bar, and their welfare, are of paramount importance to the Bar. 

The Bar Council therefore conducted two major surveys recently.  The first survey was aimed at obtaining the feedback of employer-law firms as to the attributes, skills and abilities that they deem important, and look for, when seeking to employ new law graduates, and to what extent such requirements or expectations have been met.  This employability survey was conducted with a sampling of 393 employer-law firms throughout Peninsular Malaysia who had volunteered to participate.

The second survey was conducted by the Bar Council National Young Lawyers Committee (“NYLC”), to gather data on the working conditions of the younger Members of the Bar, particularly those within the first three years of employment.  227 lawyers (predominantly in their first year of practice) and pupils in chambers participated in the survey, which yielded useful statistics on, inter alia, the work relationship between young lawyers and their employers, and the nature of remuneration received by  young lawyers.

On 20 October 2012, the NYLC held a public forum to discuss the results of the two surveys.  Based on the results of the second survey, the NYLC made the following recommendations: 

(a) Young lawyers ought to continue and strive to improve themselves, particularly by attending the Bar Council’s Continuing Professional Development seminars and courses;

(b) As a guide for employers, the proposed allowance for pupils in chambers should be a minimum of RM2,000 and RM1,000 per month, within, and outside, the  Klang Valley, respectively;

(c) As a guide for employers, the proposed remuneration for first-year lawyers should be a minimum of RM4,000 and RM2,500 per month, within, and outside, the Klang Valley, respectively; and

(d) Employers should consider including both cash and in-kind benefits in a young lawyer’s remuneration package.  For example, if a firm is unable to offer the recommended monthly amount of RM4,000 to a first-year lawyer in Kuala Lumpur, that firm could consider offering medical and dental benefits, or a telecommunication allowance, so that the value of the remuneration package would approximate the proposed figure.  This proposal represents a short-term measure in the hope that employers will eventually offer the recommended minimum salary amount in cash.

The NYLC also noted concerns expressed regarding the perceived exploitation by some employers, who offer very low amounts of remuneration.  However, while NYLC is aware that market forces ultimately dictate the level of compensation for young lawyers, NYLC hopes to persuade all employers to offer better remuneration packages, to take into account the high rate of inflation and steep cost of living.

The Bar Council’s employability survey revealed that there is divergence between the expectations and requirements of employers, and the attributes and skill sets of some of the new entrants to the Bar.  Law firms that responded identified these four skill sets and attributes as priorities: proficiency in spoken and written English; communication skills; knowledge of the law; and commitment to the firm.  The survey responses indicated that lawyers with foreign law degrees generally fare better in these areas than those with local qualifications, except where “commitment to firm” is concerned.  Within the former category of graduates, those who need not undertake the Certificate of Legal Practice (“CLP”) generally fare better than those with the CLP qualification.1

The expectations and requirements of the legal profession are dictated very much by the market, and the demands placed upon lawyers by the public, who are the consumers of legal services.  Employer-law firms were also concerned over the disparate and multiple routes of entry into the legal profession, which has led to differing standards of learning and training amongst the new entrants.  This appears to be a cause for the disparity in the skill sets and attributes detected by the survey.

An overwhelming majority of employer-law firms felt that a single entry system into the legal profession, as is the case in other jurisdictions, is desirable and viable.  To this end, they agreed that a Malaysian Common Bar Course, with a vocational training component, is needed to enhance the employability of new entrants to the Bar.

The NYLC’s forum was a useful platform for a discourse on the requisite training of young lawyers, and their work conditions.  We are therefore disappointed that The Star, in its article “Lawyers not up to par” (published on Sunday, 21 October 2012), misquoted and did not accurately represent what the speakers had said at the forum.  The Star’s generalisation about the quality of all young lawyers who have been in practice for less than seven years was an unfair and skewed portrayal that placed all the Bar’s young lawyers in a poor light.

We have strongly protested to The Star, and placed on record our unequivocal position that the employability survey covered new entrants to the Bar (and not all young lawyers), and that it is not our stand that all our young lawyers are below par.2

As a whole, the two surveys provide valuable insight on the future of the legal profession.  The Malaysian Bar aims to train, and retain, our young talents by making efforts to improve working conditions, and putting in place a comprehensive and uniform system of training, in order to be regarded as a top-notch, 21st-century legal profession.


Christopher Leong
Vice-President
Malaysian Bar

30 October 2012
____________________________________________

1 The survey reflects the views and experiences of the employer-law firms in seeking to employ new law graduates, and was not a survey to determine the quality of such law graduates per se.

2 Click here for the full version of our Letter to the Editor of The Star.

30 October 2012

Kualiti peguam muda harus ditingkatkan


http://www.utusan.com.my/utusan/Kota/20121021/wk_02/Kualiti-peguam-muda-harus-ditingkatkan





KUALA LUMPUR 20 Okt. - Majlis Peguam hari ini mendedahkan peguam muda di negara ini belum mencapai taraf kualiti antarabangsa bagi memenuhi kehendak majikan dalam pasaran kerja.

Bendaharinya, Steven Thiru berkata, kebanyakan peguam muda gagal menepati kelayakan asas seperti penguasaan bahasa Inggeris dalam penulisan dan kemahiran berkomunikasi serta pemikiran kritikal.

"Berdasarkan kaji selidik dilakukan ke atas 400 firma undang-undang di seluruh negara mendapati peguam muda termasuk pelatih tidak mempunyai asas kelayakan dan latihan yang diperlukan majikan.

"Situasi ini menyebabkan majikan terpaksa melatih golongan tersebut dari mula walaupun kemahiran itu adalah perkara harus dipelajari sejak awal lagi," katanya.

Beliau berkata demikian selepas forum tentang hasil tinjauan keadaan kerja dan pembayaran gaji bagi peguam muda negara anjuran Jawatankuasa Peguam Muda Kebangsaan (NYLC), Majlis Peguam.

Jelas beliau, kaji selidik itu juga menyatakan graduan berkelulusan undang-undang tidak kira dari universiti tempatan atau luar negara turut mengalami masalah yang sama.

"Mereka boleh menulis dan bertutur dalam bahasa Melayu, namun gagal menguasai bahasa Inggeris. Oleh sebab itu, majikan berasa sukar kerana banyak dokumen berkaitan menggunakan bahasa Inggeris," katanya.

Sehubungan itu, Steven mencadangkan kursus asas peguam diwajibkan kepada semua pengamal muda agar prestasi mereka meningkat.

Katanya, cadangan kursus tersebut masih dalam proses perbincangan setakat ini.

Dalam pada itu, Pengerusi NYLC, Richard Wee berkata, kira-kira 2,070 peguam muda yang berusia 25 hingga 30 tahun menerima gaji bulanan purata daripada RM3,001 hingga RM4,500 di sekitar Lembah Klang.

Katanya, perbezaan itu mengikut tahun perkhidmatan dari tahun pertama kepada ketiga.

Tambahnya, NYLC mencadangkan satu skim gaji iaitu RM4,000 sebulan kepada peguam muda di sekitar Lembah Klang bagi tahun pertama perkhidmatan.


Artikel Penuh: http://www.utusan.com.my/utusan/Kota/20121021/wk_02/Kualiti-peguam-muda-harus-ditingkatkan#ixzz2AmL9gbLG
© Utusan Melayu (M) Bhd 

23 October 2012

Bar Council Objects to Untrue Statements in The Star’s Article Concerning Young Lawyers







Circular No 230/2012
Dated 23 Oct 2012

To Members of the Malaysian Bar 

Bar Council Objects to Untrue Statements in The Star’s Article Concerning Young Lawyers

On 21 Oct 2012 (Sunday), The Star published an article titled “Lawyers not up to par”, concerning the Bar Council National Young Lawyers Committee’s Working Conditions Forum, held at the Bar Council on 20 Oct 2012.

The article in The Star contained sweeping and untrue statements about the quality of the Malaysian Bar’s young lawyers, which were not made by any of the speakers at the forum.  These statements are a gross misrepresentation of what the speakers had said at the forum.

We have expressed our strong protest to The Star.  We have also sent a “Letter to the Editor” to The Star setting out our unequivocal position on the matter, and have asked that the letter be published in full as soon as possible.  The Star has assured us that it will do so.

Our “Letter to the Editor” is reproduced below, along with the text of the original article that appeared in The Star.   Please click here to view the article as it appeared in The Star's e-paper.

Steven Thiru
Treasurer
Malaysian Bar

_____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________


22 Oct 2012 

Dear Editor,
Article in The Star on 21 Oct 2012 titled “Lawyers not up to par”

We refer to the article in The Star on 21 Oct 2012 (Nation, page 6) under the title “Lawyers not up to par” regarding the Bar Council’s National Young Lawyers Committee (“NYLC”) Working Conditions Forum (“Forum”), held at the Bar Council on 20 Oct 2012.  The same article appeared in the online version of The Star, titled “Young ones do not meet benchmark set by employers, says Bar”, at [this link][1] .

Paragraph 1: “All young Malaysian lawyers do not meet the standard international quality benchmark set by their employers, according to a Bar Council survey.”

This sweeping and untrue statement was not made by any of the speakers at all at the Forum.  Paragraph 1 is also not borne out by the Bar Council’s Employability Survey (“Survey”) and is therefore a grave distortion of it.  

While the Bar Council intends for the proposed Common Bar Course to be benchmarked against international standards (to ensure that lawyers entering into the profession will have the requisite quality), it is certainly not our position that all our young lawyers are below par.  The Star has made a very unfair generalisation that is a stain on the many good young lawyers at the Malaysian Bar. 

Paragraph 3: “It found that young lawyers practising for less than seven years do not have basic attributes like English proficiency, communication and critical thinking skills . . .”

This paragraph misquotes what was said.  In his presentation, Treasurer of the Malaysian Bar, Steven Thiru, emphasised that the Survey targeted a sampling of “new entrants to the legal profession”, and he explained that this group consisted of law graduates, pupils in chambers, and lawyers in their first year of practice. The survey therefore did not cover “young lawyers practising for less than seven years”. 

The Treasurer’s statement on the decline in quality was in respect of the results from the sampling of the new entrants to the legal profession covered by the Survey, and was not directed at all “young lawyers practising for less than seven years”.  The confusion on The Star’s part could have been due to NYLC being a committee that focuses on the welfare of, and issues affecting, representing lawyers of seven years’ standing and below.  However, even NYLC’s survey on working conditions was directed at first-year lawyers and not “young lawyers practising for less than seven years”.  

It is also not the position of the Bar Council that all young lawyers practising for less than seven years lack the basic attributes and skills.  The Star’s article paints a skewed and damaging picture of the Malaysian Bar’s young lawyers. 

Paragraph 14: “Thiru and other senior lawyers however, said young lawyers did not deserve the raise.”

This paragraph also misquotes what was said, as Wong Fook Meng and Steven Thiru repeatedly stressed at the Forum that employers (who are able to give the raise) would be willing to give the raise for young lawyers of quality, as it would be in the employers’ interest to do so, to retain talent.  It was also not the position of any of the speakers that a first-year lawyer, notwithstanding quality, did not deserve a raise in salary. 

In all, it was emphasised the recommendations contained in the NYLC’s survey are to serve as a non-binding guide for employer-law firms.

Across the board, The Star’s article also failed to highlight the call by the NYLC’s Chairperson, Richard Wee Thiam Seng, that young lawyers must equip themselves with better knowledge of the law and constantly improve standards.  At the same time, he also said that employers ought not exploit young lawyers by offering sub-standard salaries.  

In its entirety, the article gave the impression that all young lawyers are incapable, and that NYLC’s recommendations for better remuneration are baseless.  This was not the position taken by any of the speakers at the Forum.  To the contrary, it was the common view that the Forum was the first step towards reform in the working conditions of young lawyers, in tandem with the drive to push young lawyers to improve themselves.

We trust the above clarifies matters, and ask that The Star print this letter in full as soon as possible.
Thank you.

Yours sincerely,

Rajen Devaraj
Chief Executive Officer
Bar Council 

22 October 2012

Malaysian young lawyers not up to par

Malaysian young lawyers not up to par

KUALA LUMPUR: All young Malaysian lawyers do not meet the standard international quality benchmark set by their employers, according to a Bar Council survey. Bar Council treasurer Steven Thiru said the survey, conducted on 400 law firms, also found that employer satisfaction of new working lawyers was “shockingly low”.

“It found that young lawyers practising for less than seven years do not have basic attributes like English proficiency, communication and critical thinking skills and commitment to the profession, which is vital for the career,” said Thiru at a forum between the Bar Council and the National Young Lawyers Committee (NYLC).

He said the problem was prevalent among both local and foreign university law graduates. Thiru placed the blame on the failure of several tertiary education institutes, which did not include practical skills with academic learning. “So, what we get is law firm employers having to retrain young lawyers in basic practical skills that they should have learned in university,” he said.

 The findings come in the wake of the NYLC's recommendations to the Bar to increase the wages of young lawyers and provide more flexible working hours. The young lawyers have been complaining that they are being paid “too little” for the amount of work they do.

The NYLC, citing its own survey, said 28.2% of young lawyers in the Klang Valley wanted to leave the profession in the next five years while another 38.7% were considering leaving. Outside the Klang Valley, 15.3% said they would leave and another 48.2% were considering.

“Most cite low salaries and no work-life balance as the main reasons for opting out,” said NYLC chairman Richard Wee. He said most young lawyers were attracted to overseas firms offering better benefits. He said NYLC had suggested a starting pay of RM3,000 to RM4,000 a month for young lawyers in Klang Valley and RM2,500 for young lawyers elsewhere. The current salary is RM2,000.

He said that of the 14,500 lawyers in the country, 2,070 were considered as young.

Thiru and other senior lawyers however, said young lawyers did not deserve the raise.

Chee Siah Le Kee & Partners' Wong Fook Meng said young lawyers should earn the raise they were demanding for. “They fail to realise that they should be working to learn and better themselves as lawyers, rather than focus on the cash. “There are no shortcuts, young lawyers must create value and contribute meaningfully to their firms to justify higher compensation,” said Wong, who is a member of the Bar Council's Constitutional Law Committee and former NYLC deputy chairman.

 By NICHOLAS CHENG The Star/Asia News Network


============

Kindly take note that this was the pre-amended version which appeared in The Star on 21st OCtober 2012. Since then it has been amended to the version below:-

http://thestar.com.my/news/story.asp?file=/2012/10/21/nation/12205345&sec=nation


All new entrant lawyers do not meet employers' benchmark, says Bar



KUALA LUMPUR: All new entrant lawyers do not meet the standard international quality benchmark set by their employers, according to a Bar Council survey.
Bar Council treasurer Steven Thiru said the survey, conducted on 400 law firms, also found that employer satisfaction of new working lawyers was “shockingly low”.
“It found that new entrants to the legal profession do not have basic attributes like English proficiency, communication and critical thinking skills and commitment to the profession, which is vital for the career,” said Thiru at a forum between the Bar Council and the National Young Lawyers Committee (NYLC),
He said the problem was prevalent among both local and foreign university law graduates.
Thiru placed the blame on the failure of several tertiary education institutes, which did not include practical skills with academic learning.
“So, what we get is law firm employers having to retrain young lawyers in basic practical skills that they should have learned in university,” he said.
The findings come in the wake of the NYLC's recommendations to the Bar to increase the wages of young lawyers and provide more flexible working hours.
The young lawyers have been complaining that they are being paid “too little” for the amount of work they do.
The NYLC, citing its own survey, said 28.2% of young lawyers in the Klang Valley wanted to leave the profession in the next five years while another 38.7% were considering leaving.
Outside the Klang Valley, 15.3% said they would leave and another 48.2% were considering.
“Most cite low salaries and no work-life balance as the main reasons for opting out,” said NYLC chairman Richard Wee.
He said most young lawyers were attracted to overseas firms offering better benefits.
He said NYLC had suggested a starting pay of RM3,000 to RM4,000 a month for young lawyers in Klang Valley and RM2,500 for young lawyers elsewhere. The current salary is RM2,000.
He said that of the 14,500 lawyers in the country, 2,070 were considered as young lawyers, having worked in the profession from one to seven years.
Thiru and other senior lawyers however, said that most did not deserve the raise, which should be reserved in retaining quality lawyers that perform.
Chee Siah Le Kee & Partners' Wong Fook Meng said young lawyers should earn the raise they were demanding for.
“They fail to realise that they should be working to learn and better themselves as lawyers, rather than focus on the cash.
“There are no shortcuts, young lawyers must create value and contribute meaningfully to their firms to justify higher compensation,” said Wong, who is a member of the Bar Council's Constitutional Law Committee and former NYLC deputy chairman.